Tina Fey Tina Fey

Can we just add Tina Fey to the list of celebs who need to guest on every talk show ever? Because like Justin Timberlake, Will Arnett and Cher, the 30 Rock-er just knows how to keep the entertaining energy at a steady flow, whether she's being chatted up by Jimmy, Jay or, like last night, Andy Cohen.

Dropping in to NBC's far more fabulous sister net, the Emmy winner spent the live half-hour fielding viewer questions and calls — including one from Top Chef: Just Desserts host Gail Simmons about Rock's Ina Garten gag last week — while sipping a "Ramona Singer" (described as "white wine and collagen"), espousing her love of "cheese nights" and Pond's cold cream, and explaining the Mean Girls dynamic among The Real Housewives of New York. Turns out, someone does a killer Jill Zarin impersonation, too!

But our fave WWH moment came when Cohen convinced Fey to gamely face a round of "Would You Rather?" that touched on everything from her taste in sexy symbols to her political deal. Sure, we know where she stands on the whole Palin situation, but God love her for admitting that she'd pick spooning with Glenn Beck over bathing with Bill O'Reilly. Takes a brave soul to face either of those options, you know?

So, did you watch What Happens? Or would you rather just watch Tina Fey on 30 Rock?

Subscribe to TV Guide Magazine now!