It's been 12 years since Veronica Mars was canceled after three criminally under-watched seasons. And while we've watched and rewatched the series so many times in the years since that we can practically recite each episode from memory, we understand that the cast probably hasn't spent the past decade and a half quoting their own characters by heart. But that didn't stop us from putting them to the test!

When creator Rob Thomas and stars Jason Dohring, Enrico Colantoni, and Percy Daggs III attended the ATX Television Festival in June, we tasked them with identifying the characters behind several memorable Veronica Mars lines. So, could they tell the difference between Veronica (Kristen Bell) and Mac (Tina Majorino) quips? The nuances that separate a joke Logan (Dohring) would make and one by Keith (Colantoni)? Or what about the difference between a Paris Hilton line and a Jackie (Tessa Thompson) one?

Here's Everyone You Forgot Was on Veronica Mars

The answer: Sometimes they nailed and it and other times... not so much. But the cast and creator gave it their all, and if there's anything Veronica Mars has taught us — besides trust no one because people will always let you down — it's that you gotta roll with the good and the bad and just keep moving forward. See how they did in the full video above!

Veronica Mars is available to stream on Hulu now.

PHOTOS: Here's Everyone You Forgot Was on Veronica Mars