Exclusive Suburgatory Sneak Peek: Which Shay Is Hiding Out in George's Basement?

Suburgatory's Chatswin is a quiet place. So when George (Jeremy Sisto) hears something go bump in the night during dinner, he goes down to the basement to see what's causing the odd noise.

In this exclusive sneak peek from Wednesday's episode (9:30/8:30c on ABC), George discovers something much more horrifying than a rat or insect in his house — he discovers a Shay!

Watch full episodes of Suburgatory

So which one is now taking up residency at Casa Altman? Check out our exclusive clip:

Suburgatory airs Wednesdays at 9:30/8:30c on ABC.