This repeat of the season premiere made me recall three distinctive things: 1) It was the first episode without Noah Wyle
in the opening credits, and I remember not missing him that horribly, only because they had been downplaying Carter's importance and not featuring him as much as they usually did towards the end of last season.2) It was the first episode with Dominic Janes
as the new Alex (Sam's son). I found out literally the night after I wrote about Oliver Davis
being replaced in the role exactly why it was done: Per ER
's former casting director Sara Isaacson
, they loved Oliver, but they got tired of working around his Rodney
schedule, so they recast him. Poof! New Alex. 3) This was Linda Cardellini
's best episode this season. She did such a phenomenal job, especially when Sam finally found the missing Alex. But that's not saying much since they've turned Linda's Sam into what I like to call a "coffee-cup character" someone who stands around reacting to everyone around her, often carrying a prop like a coffee cup and sipping out of it while giving brilliant facial expressions because the writers aren't creating anything exciting for her character. Come on, ER
. Remove the coffee cup and write something exciting for Linda to do. I take it they're waiting for sweeps for Sam to finally find out about Luka and Abby dating again, let alone having a baby? Drop that cup! Dave Anderson
For a refreshing look at TV's big events each week, watch John Fugelsang and Debra Wilson deliver TV talk that's off the cuff and off the wall on TV Watercooler, Monday, 8 pm/ET, TV Guide Channel. Have a question or comment about TV for John and Debra? Submit it here.
Can't wait to see Jon Stewart host the Academy Awards? Send us your burning questions for him and he may answer you in an upcoming issue of TV Guide magazine!
Submit questions or comments for Watercooler writers via the feedback box at the bottom of this page.