Poppy Montgomery and Thomas Gibson star in a romantic comedy as carefree singles thrown together when their godchild is orphaned and his aunt (Doris Roberts) asks them to be his guardians. Waylon: Jeremy Bergman. Tina Stanfill: Tandi Wright. Craig Stanfill: Jim McLarty. Valerie: Katrina Browne. Terry Allen: Susan Brady. Judge Caldwell: Elizabeth Hawthorne.