1 of 37 Cate Cameron/The CW
3 of 37 Bob Mahoney/The CW
Ian Somerhalder, The Vampire Diaries
4 of 37 Bob D'Amico/ABC
Jesse Williams, Grey's Anatomy
6 of 37 Brian Bowen Smith/NBC
7 of 37 Tyler Golden/The CW
Justin Baldoni, Jane the Virgin
8 of 37 Neil Jabobs/CBS
Alex O'Loughlin, Hawaii Five-0
9 of 37 Bob Mahoney/The CW
Charles Michael Davis, The Originals
10 of 37 Kurt Iswarienkio/ABC
Brett Dalton, Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
11 of 37 Kurt Iswarienkio/ABC
Chace Crawford, Blood & Oil
12 of 37 Jack Rowand/ABC
Colin O'Donoghue, Once Upon a Time
13 of 37 Michael Parmelee/CBS
14 of 37 Jack Rowand/The CW
Jared Padalecki, Supernatural
15 of 37 Richard Cartwright/CBS
16 of 37 Jeff Riedel/NBC
Zachary Levi, Heroes Reborn
17 of 37 Tommy Garcia/FOX
John Stamos, Grandfathered
18 of 37 Mark Seliger/FOX
19 of 37 Jeff Neumann/CBS
Jonny Lee Miller, Elementary
20 of 37 Annette Brown/The CW
Joseph Morgan, The Originals
21 of 37 Splash
Justin Theroux, The Leftovers
22 of 37 Tyler Golden/FOX
Morris Chestnut, Rosewood
23 of 37 Greg Gayne/NBC
Philip Winchester, The Player
24 of 37 Diyah Pera/The CW
Jensen Ackles, Supernatural
26 of 37 Craig Sjodin/ABC
27 of 37 Cliff Lipson/CBS
Shemar Moore, Criminal Minds
28 of 37 Chris Haston/NBC
Taylor Kinney, Chicago Fire
29 of 37 Andrew Eccles/ABC
30 of 37 Brian Bowen Smith/FOX
31 of 37 Sonja Flemming/CBS
32 of 37 Elizabeth Morris/NBC
Jesse Spencer, Chicago Fire
33 of 37 Jack Rowand/ABC
Josh Dallas, Once Upon a Time
34 of 37 Mark Schafer/Showtime
Joshua Jackson, The Affair
35 of 37 Sonja Flemming/CBS
36 of 37 Bob Mahoney/The CW
Paul Wesley, The Vampire Diaries
37 of 37 Jim Fiscus/Showtime