James Roday Plays Who Would You Rather: Psych's Shawn Spencer or Million Little Things' Gary Mendez

James Roday plays Who Would You Rather and must choose which memorable TV character of his - Psych's Shawn Spencer or A Million Little Things' Gary Mendez - he'd choose to take along on a number of random life scenarios. With the help of his A Million Little Things co-star David Giuntoli, we put him in the hot seat. A Million Little Things airs Thursdays on ABC.