Can Henry be saved?

That is the question that has been plaguing Sleepy Hollow's second season. To find the answer, TVGuide.com traveled to the drama's Wilmington, N.C. set to ask the stars directly.

"Is he redeemable? Everyone's redeemable," John Noble says. "Something will either happen in him to turn him or kill him or make the humanity shine in him. It's [got] to be possible, doesn't it?"

On the set: Go behind the scenes of Sleepy Hollow

"He did us a great big favor," Tom Mison notes of Henry's last-minute decision to kill Moloch. However, "There's always going to be disagreement about how to deal with Henry because it's something that Abbie can't empathize with."

Find out what else the stars had to say in the video above.