Abbie vs. Katrina. It's a question as old as time — at least as old as the time Sleepy Hollowhas been on.

"There's been so much stuff online. Abbie vs. Katrina (Katia Winter) and whether she's going to steal [Ichabod] away," Nicole Beharie tells TVGuide.com on the set of the Fox drama. "Hopefully, these women are able to come together and become something greater than what they are right now."

On the set: Go behind the scenes of Sleepy Hollow

However, Tom Mison tells a different story. "It's all about Abbie. He is completely in love with her," Mison says.

Watch the stars debate Abbie vs. Katrina in the video above.