On last night's Billy Joel-themed American Idol, Kimberley Locke stole the show with her classy rendition of "New York State of Mind." And I'd like to extend special props to Locke's stylist; for once, girlfriend looked as good as she sounded. Carmen Rasmusen, meanwhile, should probably start packing her bags. She took a perfectly good ballad "And So It Goes" and butchered it to within an inch of its life. (But she's so damn sweet, I voted for her anyway.) Who do you think should follow in Rickey Smith's footsteps and get the hook tonight? Click here to vote in today's Idol poll.
Sign up and add shows to get the latest updates about your favorite shows - Start Now