Join or Sign In
Sign in to customize your TV listings
By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.
Is American Idol Really New and Improved?
Though this category is usually for shows that have an unexpected musical-themed episode (Buffy) or a character who bursts into song (everyone on Ally McBeal), it can also apply to shows themed around singing (American Idol, Gone Country, etc.). This year begs a discussion about "the new and improved" American Idol, complete with newbie fourth judge Kara DioGuardi. Do you think the mellower format of the audition shows (there's a much more balanced mix of good vs. bad auditions) and the new judge help Idol, or hurt it? Don't drama and controversy sell?
Though this category is usually for shows that have an unexpected musical-themed episode (Buffy) or a character who bursts into song (everyone on Ally McBeal), it can also apply to shows themed around singing (American Idol, Gone Country, etc.). This year begs a discussion about "the new and improved" American Idol, complete with newbie fourth judge Kara DioGuardi. Do you think the mellower format of the audition shows (there's a much more balanced mix of good vs. bad auditions) and the new judge help Idol, or hurt it? Don't drama and controversy sell?