Two years after Cole defeated his babysitter Bee and the members of her cult, he finds himself still haunted by the horrific events that happened that night. With his enemies gone, however, people begin to dismiss his fears as unfounded and consider him unstable. Melanie, his neighbor and best friend, believes otherwise, but encourages him to get past his trauma. When one day his nightmares become a reality, he has no other choice but to fight once more to survive the night.