X

Join or Sign In

Sign in to customize your TV listings

Continue with Facebook Continue with email

By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

TVGuidecom readers rank the remaining wannabes

Shaun Harrison
AIRanking-TopFour-SyeshaMercado4.JPG
1 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFour-SyeshaMercado4

No. 4) Syesha Mercado has placed last or next-to-last in every poll to date, yet has steadily increased her vote count over the past six weeks. Can she survive another round
2 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFour-SyeshaMercado8

TVGuide.com readers rate Syesha: "She's the only girl in the competition now, and she's the only girl that deserves to be in the competition now." (kimberlyanne89)
3 of 12 Michael Bezjian/WireImage.com

AIRanking-TopFour-SyeshaMercado12

TVGuide.com readers rate Syesha: "She will have a great career - on Broadway - unless she wows us with more modern-sounding numbers in the weeks to come." (Darcey)
4 of 12 Fox

AIRanking-TopFour-JasonCastro7

No. 3) Jason's placing on the Power Rankings has been a see-saw as of late. This week he dropped two points to just under 10 percent.
5 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFour-JasonCastro3

TVGuide.com readers rate Jason: "It takes personality, charisma, a unique style and good vocals [to win Idol]. Jason excels in all these categories." (lisalexo) 
6 of 12 Michael Bezjian/WireImage.com

AIRanking-TopFour-JasonCastro11

TVGuide.com readers rate Jason: "He has as much charisma as a washcloth. Jason has to go!" (heidit) "Too one-dimensional." (bangle)
7 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFour-DavidArchuleta1

No. 2) David Archuleta reversed a two-week slide by boosting his vote tally to 22.8 percent. Is it the start of a final run for the title
8 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFour-DavidArchuleta5

TVGuide.com readers rate David A.: "He's so 'cute' and humble. He has a really good voice, as well. (kevin) "Archuleta! Cook is so arrogant, I just want to slap him." (dorkyderk)
9 of 12 Michael Bezjian/WireImage.com

AIRanking-TopFour-DavidArchuleta9

TVGuide.com readers rate David A.: "He has such a great voice, but I'm just not interested in what he sings -  [and] I usually rally behind the best pure singer." (sarah)
10 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFour-DavidCook2

No. 1) David Cook is holding strong, garnering his best-ever numbers - 62.4 percent of your vote - when it's needed most.
11 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFour-DavidCook6

TVGuide.com readers rate David C.: "Kelly Clarkson, Clay Aiken and Melinda Doolittle possess the best voices that ever graced the Idol stage, but David Cook's whole approach is original." (Pisces228)
12 of 12 Michael Bezjian/WireImage.com

AIRanking-TopFour-DavidCook10

TVGuide.com readers rate David C.: "David Archuleta is the next Idol. Cook is soooooo boring." (badazztyler)