Who Do You Believe?
Simultaneous storytelling takes viewers through compelling true-crime cases from dual perspectives. The audience steps into the shoes of two contrasting narratives to hear the recounts directly from the victims and criminals with never-before-revealed details. The viewers will play armchair detective to deduce and piece together different versions of the truth. There are two sides to every story -- and there's no telling how far one would go for their marriage, child or way of life. Every episode culminates by revealing key details from the adjudicated cases leaving viewers to question: "Who Do You Believe?"
- 2022-2022
- 1 season
- ABC
- Suspense
- TV-14
Simultaneous storytelling takes viewers through compelling true-crime cases from dual perspectives. The audience steps into the shoes of two contrasting narratives to hear the recounts directly from the victims and criminals with never-before-revealed details. The viewers will play armchair detective to deduce and piece together different versions of the truth. There are two sides to every story -- and there's no telling how far one would go for their marriage, child or way of life. Every episode culminates by revealing key details from the adjudicated cases leaving viewers to question: "Who Do You Believe?"
Season 1 Episode Guide
8 Episodes 2022
Episode 1
Overwhelming Charity
Tue, May 3, 2022
Secrets from the past are revealed as newly married Mark and Charity navigate their rocky relationship.
Episode 2
Protector Vs. Predator
Tue, May 10, 2022
Actress Nichelle Nichols is caught between her son Kyle Johnson and her former business manager Gilbert Bell in a vicious and public battle for her conservatorship.
Episode 3
What the Sisters Saw - Part 1
Tue, May 17, 2022
Celeste is a struggling mother of twin teenage girls, fighting to reunite her children after they were split apart in a bitter custody battle. While working as a country club waitress, she meets and marries Steven Beard, a man more than 40 years her senior who is worth millions. The marriage seemingly gives Celeste and her daughters Jennifer and Kristina a brief storybook life that is shattered by a late-night shotgun blast that leaves one of them dead and the others fighting over the truth of what really happened. Does mother know best, or does she have something to hide?
Episode 4
What the Sisters Saw - Part 2
Tue, May 31, 2022
The riveting battle between Celeste Beard and her twin teenage daughters continues to unfold in part two of this unbelievable true-crime story. Secret recordings and a shocking confession point suspicion toward Celeste and her best friend's possible involvement. When the walls start closing in on Celeste, her daughters go on the run fearing their own lives could be in danger. With family members now foes, who is to blame for their epic collapse and who is telling the truth?
Episode 5
Slayed While Sleeping
Tue, Jun 7, 2022
Maypearl, Texas, January 2, 2018: Sandra Garner called 911 and said her husband Jon Garner, age 42, had been shot by a masked intruder. When the authorities arrived, they were unable to save Jon's life. In a curious case where evidence suddenly materializes and accusations fly, the police are puzzled. The mother and son Wes Miller are now blaming each other for the murder. Police body cameras will help solve the murder.
Episode 6
Flag of Our Father
Fri, Jun 3, 2022
Episode 7
Kill Thy Neighbor
Tue, Jul 5, 2022
On April 15, 2019, Marc Anthony Williams, age 49, from the Five-Points neighborhood of Detroit, Michigan, was killed after he was shot multiple times by his neighbor Chazmun Conley, age 33, who claims he killed Williams in self-defense.
Episode 8
Dad's Deadly Deeds
Tue, Jul 12, 2022
When she is seven years old, Jordynn Watson's mother goes missing and her grandmother Marilyn is gunned down. Detectives work the case, but eventually the leads go cold. Later, when the case heats up again, Jordynn battles with Detective Kelly Anderson who thinks her father is the one who murdered her mother and grandmother, but Jordynn is convinced that her father is innocent.