Professional matchmaker Angie Dove is surprised to run into her old college boyfriend Ethan Plume, who has just taken the reins at his family's publishing house. But a bigger shock is yet to come, as bestselling writer Beatrice Penn suddenly takes ill onstage, the victim of a fatal dose of poison. Though bad blood between Ethan and Beatrice makes him the prime suspect, Angie knows he's incapable of murder.