Join or Sign In

Sign in to customize your TV listings

Continue with Facebook Continue with email

By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

The Queer Eye Guys Competed on Nailed It and OMFG

This is almost too much for us to handle

Sadie Gennis

Move over, American Horror Story. This is the only crossover we care about anymore.

On Friday, Netflix surprised fans by releasing a bonus episode of the baking competition series Nailed Itfeaturing everyone's five favorite internet boyfriends, the Queer Eye guys!

Antoni Porowski, Jonathan Van Ness, Tan France, Karamo Brown and Bobby Berk joined Nailed It host Nicole Byer in the kitchen, where they were tasked with recreating tasty replicas of the cast made out of cupcakes and cake pops. But in a twist, resident babe Antoni was excluded from the competition because, as Queer Eye's food and wine expert, he was recruited to guest-judge his co-stars!

With Antoni out of the mix, the friendly competition between the four remaining guys heated up... kind of. Tan asked Karamo to team up in order to take down Bobby and Jonathan, but we bet Tan regretted that choice pretty quickly.

Almost immediately, Karamo's lack of skills in the kitchen left a lot to be desired from a teammate but also just from a grown human being. Karamo struggled so much with the challenge that he straight-up walked away from the competition completely at one point in order to drink rosé with Nicole, Antoni and pastry chef Jacques Torres.

But after a quick pep talk from Nicole, Karamo got back in the game -- to the best of his ability, at least.

Karamo Brown, Nailed It

Meanwhile, over at Bobby and Jonathan's table, Jonathan was having a mini-meltdown of his own, which included him trying to steal Tan's fondant and distracting Bobby because he couldn't handle how much better he was doing in the competition. Despite all this, Jonathan still insisted that he finished the challenge first and simply stood back and snacked while his co-stars continued to work tirelessly. (Spoiler alert: He was not finished.)

​Jonathan Van Ness, Nailed It

When it came to judging, the winner was pretty clear. Bobby's strategic decision to choose Jonathan's bearded cake pop so that he could hide any "neck issues" really paid off and he took home the special blinged-out Nailed It trophy chain.

Check out all the Queer Eye cast's hilarious desserts below, but prepare yourselves. Some of them are not pretty.

Nailed It

Karamo's attempt at Bobby

Nailed It

Tan's attempt at Karamo

Nailed It

Jonathan's attempt at Tan

Nailed It

Bobby's attempt at Jonathan


Watch full seasons of Nailed It and Queer Eye on Netflix now. You can also catch an extended version of the crossover episode right here.