Amazon Prime Video Top 10 Shows and Movies: New and Trending Today, September 12

The Amazon Prime Video top 10 movies and shows list is all topsy-turvy, with The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power the lone consistent show at No. 1. No. 2 is a surprise: Tim Gunn and Heidi Klum's fashion competition series Making the Cut climbs the rankings to the highest spot it's been in during Season 3. A League of Their Own continues its appearing and disappearing act, joining the list again at No. 8. But there's more potential chaos coming this week: How will this list handle Thursday Night Football, which premieres this Thursday? It's a show, but it also isn't a show, right?

The top 10 movies and shows on Prime Video are listed below, but we're not just listing them; we're also putting our opinions on there to help you figure out which are worth watching. And to help you plan what you'll watch next, we've added the new shows and movies coming to Prime Video, too.

Coming soon to Prime Video:

• The NFL Pile On - Taran Killam hosts this comedic sports special. (Sept. 14, 7 p.m. ET)
• Thursday Night Football - Prime Video is the exclusive home for the NFL on Thursday nights. This week: Patrick Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs host so-far-fantasy-bust Austin Ekeler (DO BETTER, AUSTIN) and the Los Angeles Chargers in an AFC West battle that will include like a zillion touchdowns. (Sept. 15)
• Goodnight Mommy - Naomi Watts stars in this remake of the 2015 Austrian horror film about two kids who begin to think their mother isn't who she says she is. (Sept. 16)
• The Grand Tour Presents: A Scandi Flick - James, Richard, and Jeremy bring their rambunctious road tour north of the Arctic Circle in this special. (Sept. 16) 

Recently released on Prime Video:

• Flight/Risk - This documentary film investigates two crashes of Boeing 737s that happened just months apart. Yes, it's the same topic that Netflix's Downfall: The Case Against Boeing covered earlier this year. (Sept. 9)

Amazon Prime Video Top 10 Shows and Movies: New and Popular Today, September 13

Amazon Prime Video Top 10 Shows and Movies: New and Popular Today, September 9

Top 10 TV Shows and Movies on Amazon Prime Video

1. The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

For fans of: Elves, orcs, dwarves, hobbits, etc.
Is it good?: It lives up to the high expectations placed on it [Review]
Trailer | Friday's rank: 1

2. Making the Cut

For fans of: Project Runway, fashion, Gunn and Klum
Is it good?: It's one of Amazon's better reality series, but it doesn't stray from the familiar formula
Trailer | Friday's rank: 8

3. Reacher

For fans of: Huge dudes kicking butt and doing detective work
Is it good?: Amazon's hit action show is great and will be around for a long time [Review]
Trailer | Friday's rank: 3

4. Samaritan

For fans of: Superheroes, Sylvester Stallone beating up Robocop-type street crooks
Is it good?: It's just an OK dark superhero film [Review]
Trailer | Friday's rank: 4

5. The Boys

For fans of: Superheroes, superjerks, superviolence
Is it good?: It's one of TV's best, and certainly the best satirical superhero series
Trailer | Friday's rank: 2

More on Amazon:

• The Best TV Shows on Amazon Prime Video Right Now
• The Best Movies on Amazon Prime Video Right Now
• New Amazon Prime Video Shows and Movies Coming in September
• The Ultimate Guide to Streaming in September

6. The Terminal List

For fans of: Chris Pratt, military thrillers, tough guys 
Is it good?: It's a solid shoot 'em up adaptation of Jack Carr's book [Review]
Trailer | Friday's rank: 5

7. The Wheel of Time

For fans of: The Lord of the Rings
Is it good?: It's another deep fantasy universe, but not quite on the scale of The Rings of Power [Review]
Trailer | Friday's rank: 6

8. A League of Their Own

For fans of: Baseball yuksters, queer stories, killer casts
Is it good?: This delightful remix of the 1992 film goes deeper into important topics but still stays fun [Review]
Trailer | Friday's rank: n/a

9. The Summer I Turned Pretty

For fans of: Teen romance, beach vacations, love triangles, Abercrombie vibes
Is it good?: For a page-turning YA drama, it delivers the goods
Trailer | Friday's rank: 7

10. The Lost City

For fans of: Sweaty A-listers, Romancing the Stone
Is it good?: Sandra Bullock and Channing Tatum make for a fun pair of novice adventurists in this crowd-pleasing genre blend
Trailer | Friday's rank: 9

Based on Amazon Prime Video's Top 10 Movies and TV Shows list for Monday, Sept. 12