True Crime Story: It Couldn't Happen Here
Small town native and advocate Hilarie Burton Morgan explores controversial small town murder cases
- 2021-2026
- 4 seasons
- SundanceTV
- Documentary, Suspense
- TV-14
Small town native and advocate Hilarie Burton Morgan explores controversial small town murder cases
Season 4 Episode Guide
6 Episodes 2026
Episode 1
Corsicana, Texas
Thu, Feb 19, 2026
In Corsicana, Texas, when a young woman from a wealthy family is found dead in a river, suspicion falls on her well-connected husband. But a district attorney's shady misdeeds forever alter the course of the investigation, while her family continues to fight for justice.
Episode 2
State College, Pennsylvania
Thu, Feb 26, 2026
State College, Pennsylvania. A college town is turned upside down when a young man is convicted of his friend's murder. But after more than 3 decades behind bars, previously concealed evidence is uncovered that could prove the convicted man's innocence.
Episode 3
Brownstown, Indiana
Thu, Mar 5, 2026
In Brownstown, Indiana, In 2021, Ta'Neasha Chappell, a single mother, is arrested for shoplifting and thrown into the local jail. She is the only Black woman in the jail. While in custody, she mysteriously falls ill. She cries for help for more than 19 hours, but the jail staff disregards her pleas. She ultimately dies in custody.
Episode 4
Love County, Oklahoma
Thu, Mar 12, 2026
In Love County, Oklahoma, two young people, Molly Miller and Colt Haynes go missing on Chickasaw land. They were passengers in a car driven by another young man, who leads police on a high speed chase. The next day, the driver is home, but Molly and Colt are nowhere to be found. Competing jurisdictions, a scandalized sheriff, and cover-up accusations complicate the families' search for answers.
Episode 5
Mayfield, Kentucky
Thu, Mar 19, 2026
In Mayfield, Kentucky, when a young mother, Jessica Currin, is found murdered behind the middle school, multiple law enforcement agencies struggle to solve the case. However, a local amateur sleuth takes the investigation into her own hands and leads to a breakthrough - but questions remain regarding who really killed Jessica Currin.
Episode 6
Gilmer, Texas
Thu, Mar 26, 2026
In the East Texas town of Gilmer a high school girl, Kelly Wilson, goes missing. Local townspeople begin to believe a Satanic cult is to blame. Suspected cult members are arrested for the girls murder - including the lead police investigator. But an outside investigator re-opens the investigation and discovers that things in Gilmer are not as they appear.