Join or Sign In

Sign in to customize your TV listings

Continue with Facebook Continue with email

By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

What Songs Does American Idol Need to Retire?

Please, not "I'll be again!"

Sadie Gennis

American Idoldoesn't exactly have a reputation for being the most hip and with-it show on the air. And we get that. It's hard to stay fresh after 14 seasons - especially when contestants sing the exact same songs. Every. Single. Year.

Watch Jennifer Lopez's hysterical emoji impression

Over the past decade and a half, contestants who have been lucky enough to make it to the live shows have celebrated with a performance of Aerosmith's "I Don't Wanna Miss a Thing" eight separate times. That means if you tune in to any random season of Idol, there is more than a 60 percent chance that you will be subjected to yet another cover of this 1998 karaoke go-to. (And Fox wonders why many people prefer The Voice.)

The number of times women decide to show off their "edgy" side with a rendition of Heart's "Alone" or Janis Joplin's "Piece of My Heart"? Six. Each. That's the same number of times contestants have performed the frustratingly un-killable One Tree Hill theme song "I Don't Wanna Be." Gratuities from American Idol alone probably feed Gavin DeGraw for a week.

Surprisingly, the audition favorite "I'll Be" by Edwin McCain has only been performed on the live shows five times, but that's still five too many in our opinion.