Melanie Martinez, Caitlin Michelle Melanie Martinez, Caitlin Michelle

The biggest moment of Tuesday's The Voice wasn't any rockin', upbeat song-and-dance number. Instead, it was the haunting simplicity of Caitlin Michele and Melanie Martinez's cover of "Lights." The Team Adam members each had a unique take on the Ellie Goulding song, sending shivers down our spines. But what did the judges think?

"It was probably the prettiest and most moving performance of the whole day," Christina Aguilera praised. And she wasn't the only one impressed by the indie duo. Neither Xtina nor Blake Shelton could pick a battle winner. When pressed, Cee Lo Green tossed his support behind Martinez.

Did The Voice's New twist steal your heart? Weigh in on the battles!

Adam Levine mused that the other coaches were reluctant to pick a favorite because they planned on stealing whoever wasn't chosen. But was the coach right?

Find out who Levine chose and whether or not any of the other coaches stole his newly discarded contestant in the video below: