Maybe they should rename the show American Most Wanted. American Idol finalist Trenyce is the latest contestant on the Fox reality show to get "outed" by Court TV's According to the site, the 22-year-old Memphis crooner — whose real name is Lashundra Cobbins — was busted in October 1999 on a felony shoplifting charge, for which she was placed the following year in a pre-trial diversion program by a Criminal Court judge. Idol producers were reportedly aware that Trenyce pulled a Winona Ryder, and therefore, she's in no danger of getting tossed off the show. Somewhere, Frenchie Davis is consulting her legal team.