Vanessa Marano. Sean Berdy Vanessa Marano. Sean Berdy

Switched at Birth's Bay (Vanessa Marano) might believe she did the right thing by taking the fall so Daphne (Katie LeClerc) avoids jail time, but one person who doesn't see it that way is her boyfriend Emmett (Sean Berdy).

ABC Family announces premiere dates for Pretty Little Liars, Switched at Birth, more

In our exclusive first look at the show's Season 4 premiere, Bay and Daphne have to explain to their families that at the last minute, Bay told the police she was actually the one who vandalized the property and not Daphne, who would have to serve time due to her past record. But Bay's hasty decision doesn't just affect the two of them. Now, instead of joining Emmett in Los Angeles for college, she'll have to face the penalties of what she's "done."

"I didn't want to be talked out of it and I knew if it didn't go through with it, I was going to regret it every single day knowing I could've done something and didn't," Bay tries to explain to Emmett, who is not happy with her actions.

Do you think Bay made the right choice?


Switched at Birth returns on Tuesday, Jan. 6 at 9/8c on ABC Family.