Gabriel Macht Gabriel Macht

Last week's episode of Suits left everyone feeling betrayed after Mike (Patrick J. Adams) discovered that it was Stephen (Max Beasley) who ordered the murders of dissidents Ava is being held responsible for. However, no one feels more slighted than Stephen's (now former) lady love, Donna (Sarah Rafferty).

In this exclusive sneak peek from Tuesday's episode (10/9c, USA), Donna begins to question herself as she helps Harvey (Gabriel Macht) nurse his bruises from his epic men's bathroom throwdown with Stephen.

Fall TV: Must-watch new shows

"I was with him. And he was capable of something like that and I didn't even see it," Donna says. "Just tell me you're going to make him pay."

See how Harvey responds in the exclusive clip below:

Suits airs Tuesdays at 10/9c on USA.