In addition to dishing about their first dates and the best ways to go skinny-dipping, Michele and Palmer also revealed their very first celebrity crushes.
"I loved Michael Jordan," Michele admits. "I had a photo of him. I used to kiss him every single day and I told my mother I was going to marry him."
"Weirdly, went from Michael Jordan to JTT," Michele continues.
"Who's JTT?" Palmer asks, prompting Michele (and us) to feel extremely old.
Watch the hilarious video below:
Scream Queens airs Tuesdays at 9/8c on Fox.