Andrea Boehlke, John Cochran and Malcolm Freberg Andrea Boehlke, John Cochran and Malcolm Freberg

It hasn't been a good couple of days for Jeff Probst.

A day after his daytime talk show was canceled, Survivor: Caramoan — Fans vs. Favorites opened to the series' lowest premiere ever, falling 23 percent to 9 million viewers and a 2.4 in the adults 18-to-49 demographic. Lead-out CSI (9.1 million, 2.1) dropped three-tenths.

American Idol (13.4 million, 4.3) also had down night, slipping to its lowest demo rating since its first season in July 2002.

Winter TV Preview: Must-see new shows

Most of ABC's and NBC's shows were flat or rebounded from last week's numbers, with Modern Family (10 million, 3.8) rising a tenth from a season low.On The CW,

Arrow (3.3 million, 1.1) and Supernatural (2.5 million, 1.0) were up and flat, respectively. 8 p.m.
Survivor: Caramoan — Fans vs. Favorites 9 million viewers (2.4 demo rating) [8-9:30 p.m.]ABC: The Middle 7.6 million (1.9); The Neighbors 5.9 million (1.7)NBC: Whitney 3.6 million (1.2); Guys with Kids 2.8 million (1.0)Fox: American Idol 13.4 million (4.3) [8-10 p.m.]CW: Arrow 3.3 million (1.1)9 p.m.
The Big Bang Theory (R) 5.8 million (1.6) [9:30-10 p.m.]ABC: Modern Family 10 million (3.8); Suburgatory 6.1  million (2.2)NBC: Law & Order: Special Victims Unit 6.3 million (1.6)CW: Supernatural 2.5 million (1.0)10 p.m.
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation 9.1 million (2.1)NBC: Chicago Fire 6.6 million (1.9)ABC: Nashville 5.7 million (1.8)