Joshua McKinley, Andrae Gonzalo Joshua McKinley, Andrae Gonzalo

What happened to Andrae?

Santino Rice's famous query will finally be answered this year when Andrae Gonzalo returns for the second season of Lifetime's Project Runway All Stars, the network announced.

Project Runway All Stars' Mondo: I wanted to strangle myself

He'll be joined by 12 other former contestants: Wendy Pepper (season one); Kayne Gillaspie and Uli Herzner (season three); Suede Baum (season five); Althea Harper (season six); Emilio Sosa (season seven); Peach Carr, Ivy Higa and Cassanova (season eight); and Joshua McKinley, Laura Kathleen and Anthony Ryan Auld (season nine).Season 1 host Angela Lindvall has been replaced by model Carolyn Murphy. Katie Holmes will appear as one of the season's  guest judges.Project Runway All Stars returns Oct. 25 at 9/8c on Lifetime.