There have been so many atrocious acts committed over Pretty Little Liars' six-season run that it can be hard to keep them straight - even for the show's stars! quizzed Pretty Little Liars' cast and producers about whether an act was committed by A or a bae, meaning any of the show's seemingly endless supply of good looking men who become entangled in the liars' lives.

So how did they do? Check out in the video above.

Pretty Little Liars returns Tuesday, January 12 at 8/7c on Freeform.