Noah Centineo Hilariously Recreated Classic Rom-Coms with James Corden

America's dreamboy Noah Centineo recreated his hit movie To All the Boys I've Loved Before on The Late Late Show Thursday night with James Corden playing the Lara Jean Covey to his Peter Kavinsky, and it was charming and hilarious and all the things you would expect from the biggest new movie star of 2018. You could say it had us going "whoa whoa whoa."

The sketch follows the plot of the movie with a late-night twist, as Centineo gets a letter Corden wrote to him asking him to be a guest on his show. They do all the cute Lara Jean and Peter stuff, including the iconic hands in back pockets and spin.

Then when it's time for Corden to win Centineo back, he breaks out Andrew Lincoln's signs from Love Actually, and Centineo relents, saying "You had me at hello." (To all the Gen Z kids who might not know, that's from Jerry Maguire.)

The Late Late Show airs weeknights at 12:35/11:35c on CBS.
(Full disclosure: TV Guide is owned by CBS.)