E! News first reported Carpenter's pregnancy after the actress' growing baby bump was spotted in Los Angeles during a coffee run on Saturday.
Carpenter and Avett, one of the members of the band The Avett Brothers, have been dating for nearly two years. Carpenter was previously married to her Dexter co-star Michael C. Hall, but the couple divorced in 2011.
TODAY'S VIDEO: Can the Sleepy Hollow stars guess the headless celeb?