Did the Idol Boys Fall Flat?

That seems to be the consensus from what we’re hearing, and not just from the judges. Of the twelve, only a handful seemed to stand out from the group's boring and off-key tunes. But we have to give credit to youngin’ of the bunch, seventeen year-old David Archuleta who actually managed to win over Simon. Let’s see if the ladies have what it takes to keep us entertained tonight (or awake for that matter). Your take: How do you feel the guys performed last night? Were you all about David or did another contestant’s ditty blow you away?