The Bachelorette The Bachelorette

Cheers to The Bachelorette's Ali Fedotowsky for cutting screwy Kasey loose.

It may have been hard to tell what the mush-mouthed ad exec was saying — even with the subtitles during his love poem! — but there was no mistaking the fact that he's bughouse loony. In a frightening attempt to prove he was there to "guard and protect her heart" (an oft-repeated phrase that no doubt launched a thousand drinking games), Kasey got a tattoo of a heart with a shield and 11 studs, representing the 11 studs who were chasing after her. (Ew.)

Want more Bachelorette scoop? Subscribe to TV Guide Magazine.

He revealed this ink to Ali on an Icelandic volcano — where better? — and she promptly gave him the "You are so ready to meet someone" (read: someone else) speech. Then she took off in a helicopter with professional wrestler (!) Justin, leaving Kasey standing alone on a glacier. (Note to producers: That's cold!) To be fair, Ali did say before the date, "The only thing he needs to do is be normal." And at that, Kasey failed spectacularly.

Another good call: At the rose ceremony, Ali sent non-entity Chris N. packing. In the limo, the entrepreneur burbled, "I'm at a loss for words, to be honest with you." When wasn't he at a loss for words? After she asked him about his guilty pleasure, the David Duchovny lookalike choked: "I really love Mexican food." Adios!

Do you think Ali sent the right guys home?

Subscribe to TV Guide Magazine now!