Nick Carter Nick Carter

Nick Carter has quit playing games with his heart: The Backstreet Boy got engaged to girlfriend Lauren Kitt on Wednesday, according to US Weekly.

Check out the stars who don't look their age

Carter, 33, proposed to the 29-year-old fitness expert and actress on an island in the Florida Keys. Carter teased the proposal on Instagram, posting a photo of the pair with a caption that read, "Big question... Great answer."

This will be the first marriage for Carter, who is currently working with his fellow Backstreet Boys on a new album.