American Horror Story might be known for its spooks, scares, and all the wild things the characters do, but it really doesn't get celebrated enough for what the characters say. This show is so quotable we wonder if some of the writers on staff may have made a deal with Papa Legba!

The language on American Horror Story is as out of the box as some of the twists. So in honor of that, we decided to put the cast of the FX anthology to the test to see if they can tell the difference between quotes from American Horror Story and quotes from the equally out of the box American Horror Story veteran Lady Gaga.

At Saturday's American Horror Story 100th episode celebration, TV Guide quizzed Sarah Paulson, Angela Bassett, Lily Rabe, Cody Fern, Cheyenne Jackson, Leslie Grossman, Zach Villa, Gus Kenworthy, Matthew Morrison, Angelica Ross, and Jamie Brewer to see if they could tell the monsters of American Horror Story apart from their Mother Monster in the video above. And you know what the general consensus was?

"Basically, what I think is that everything that is written on AHS, Gaga could have said," Paulson declared.

American Horror Story: 1984 airs Wednesdays at 10/9c on FX.