American Horror Story quickly solidified Peters as a beloved internet boyfriend once Murder House introduced him as Tate Langdon in 2011. In the seven years since, fans' love for him has only grown as he's taken on new roles that show off his range when it comes to both acting and adorable hairstyles. Even when Peters began taking on more villainous roles starting in Hotel, the actor's natural charisma has resulted in plenty of fans swooning over his nefarious roles, or at the very least obsessing over them platonically when Peters' characters are too cruel to every be truly redeemed (hi, Kai!).
But which of Peters' American Horror Story roles is your soulmate? Find out whether you'll be sailing off into the sunset with Tate Langdon, living out your happily ever afterlife with Mr. March or falling for one of his other AHS roles by taking the quiz below.
American Horror Story: Apocalypse airs Wednesdays at 10/9c on FX.