If you like your TV with a side of Hallmark vibes and a quaint small-town energy, the Good Witch series finale was probably a very bittersweet moment for you. After seven seasons, Hallmark's series about a mother-daughter witch duo living in a quirky small town signed off, and we're already missing our magical catch-ups with Cassie (Catherine Bell) and Grace (Bailee Madison). Still, it's possible to love again, and we've taken the liberty of rounding up the shows that will make you feel just as comforted as Good Witch did.
All of the little elements that make Good Witch such a fun series can be found in other shows, so if you're looking for something similar to watch next, we've got you covered! From magical teens to small-town drama, here are a few series like Good Witch that you should watch next!
The first and most obvious choice as a substitute is to watch any of Hallmark's The Good Witch TV movies that the series spun off from. It may seem crazy, but there are actually fans out there that didn't watch these movies before watching the TV show. If you're one of them, hop on these prequels ASAP and then do a series rewatch. You'll thank us later. They're full of storylines that have gotten shoutouts on the series, including Cassie's love story with her first husband, who left her a widow in the pilot. [Watch on Amazon Prime with Hallmark Movies Now]
If you're looking for a series that has all the small-town drama of Good Witch with a little more magic and monsters on the side, Legacies is the show for you. Set in a small town with a secret magical school for youngsters, Legacies focuses on a group of teen witches, vampires, werewolves, and other supernatural creatures as they try to defend their home from weekly incursions of monsters. Be warned though, Legacies is a spin-off of The Originals, which is itself a spin-off of The Vampire Diaries, so binge-watching this show might tempt you to binge the other two, and that might occupy the rest of your year. [Watch on Netflix, The CW]
This one might seem like an odd addition to the list, but there's just no denying the similarities between Gilmore Girls and Good Witch. They both follow a single mother raising her daughter in an eccentric American town with enough hijinks to create years of good TV. From the nosy mayor to the "new kid in town" romantic subplots, these two series surprisingly have more in common than not. The only real difference is that Lorelai (Lauren Graham) and Rory's (Alexis Bledel) "powers" are the ability to drink endless amounts of coffee and talk double-time. [Watch on Netflix]
We can't imagine a world in which any fans of Good Witch have not also watched every season of Witches of East End, but if that's the case, you're in for a treat. This series might be less wholesome than you're looking for -- the benefits of being on Lifetime instead of Hallmark -- but it has that uncanny ability to melt your heart. The witches in the series also come complete with past lives and eternal youth in some cases, so there are so seriously cool flashbacks to keep things interesting when you're not focused on the steamy romances. [Watch on Hulu, IMDb TV (free with ads)]
If you loved Cassie's teenage daughter Grace's storylines in Good Witch, we suggest a short and sweet binge of The CW's The Secret Circle. Though it ventures a little further into the dark side of magic, The Secret Circle indulges in all the juicy teen drama of young witches discovering and learning to use their powers while trying to keep a lot of odd behavior secret. There's also a great mystery at the heart of the show, so even though it got canceled after only one season, it's still worth a look! [Watch on CW Seed]
Netflix's Sweet Magnolias may not have the supernatural element you love from Good Witch, but it's got all the same quaint, character-driven story arcs you'll know and love. A single mom in a small town finding unexpected love while gossipy townies get in the way at every turn? Yep, sure sounds like a great Good Witch alternative to us! And just like Good Witch, Sweet Magnolias makes the excellent point that your first epic love doesn't always have to be your last. [Watch on Netflix] [More shows like Sweet Magnolias]
If you're looking for a show that's got major "kick back with a glass of wine and just forget about the world for a while" vibes, Hallmark's When Calls the Heart is your ticket. Set in frontier times, this series has all the good hallmarks (see what we did there?) of a feel-good story full of happiness and heartbreak. If you're looking for a slow-burn love story that just a wholesome as Cassie and Sam's, this should definitely be your next binge. And with seven seasons under its belt, this one will definitely keep you glued to your TV for a while. [Watch on Amazon Prime (for purchase)]
If you're in the mood to double down on magical shenanigans and girl power, the CW's Charmed reboot has a modern take on a family of witches balancing their personal lives with their magical ones. Rather than a mother/daughter duo, Charmed tells the story of three sister witches whose problems range from rushing college sororities to fighting the Source of All Evil. Talk about women who can multi-task! This show also has a fun vibe that hooks you in and really lets you invest in the character's personal lives, just like Good Witch! [Watch on Netflix, The CW]
Good Witch Seasons 1-5 are now streaming on Netflix.