X

Join or Sign In

Sign in to customize your TV listings

Continue with Facebook Continue with email

By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

Mistletoe Murders

Emily Lane has recently moved to the small town of Forest Grove NY where she owns and operates Under the Mistletoe, a year 'round Christmas store. This outwardly quiet life belies her secret past, she having moved there to escape that past. She is finding that regardless of wanting to hide from that past, she can't help but insert herself into troublesome situations especially when it comes to murders in town. She also finds that she rides a fine line in hiding that past as she does her own research about "Chimera" who would be out to get her if they knew where she was, and as she begins a friendship/romantic relationship with Sam Wilner, the town's police detective.

Loading. Please wait...

Content not available in your region? ExpressVPN can help you stay connected wherever you are. Get 4 extra months FREE with TV Guide's exclusive offer.

Cast & Crew See All

Sarah Drew
Emily Lane
Peter Mooney
Sam Wilner
Sierra Marilyn Riley
Violet Wilner

Season 2 Episode Guide See All

Episode 1

Cold War Part 1

Fri, Nov 7, 202542 mins

There has been an eleven month freeze in Emily and Sam's relationship, ever since last Christmas as Sam didn't feel like he could trust her, especially with Violet, without Emily answering questions about her past, questions she didn't feel like she could answer for him. With the Christmas season approaching again, Violet, unaware of the issue between her father and Emily, is hinting that she'd like her old job at the Mistletoe back. Emily feels compelled unofficially to look into the "disappearance" of someone important in Violet's life, her English teacher, Tim Henley, the double quotes as he is not officially missing in having abruptly submitted his resignation to deal with a personal issue. He became an even more integrated part of her life as he was the coach of the school's chess club, its star player, Kyle Granger, on who Violet has been crushing and who Mr. Henley had asked Violet to tutor in he failing English, a failing grade which would preclude him from being on the chess team and thwart his chances of receiving a scholarship. But as Emily investigates and believes foul play has indeed occurred, she has to convince Sam of Tim truly having disappeared, before she can insert herself into an official investigation.

Where to Watch

Featured Video

Mistletoe Murders
Mistletoe Murders
0:28

0:28 Mistletoe Murders

Awards

  • 2025 - Canadian Screen Award - Best Writing, Drama Series - nominated
  • 2025 - Canadian Screen Award - Best Original Music, Drama - nominated

You May Also Like See All

The Office
Homicide: Life on the Street
The Staircase
The Sopranos

Popular Shows See all shows

Landman

3 Seasons
Set in the proverbial boomtowns of West Texas, Landman is a modern-day tale of fortune seeking in the world of oil rigs. Based on the notable 11-part podcast “Boomtown” from Imperative Entertainment and Texas Monthly, the series is an upstairs/downstairs story of roughnecks and wildcat billionaires fueling a boom so big, it’s reshaping our climate, our economy and our geopolitics.

Best Medicine

1 Season
A brilliant surgeon leaves Boston to become a doctor in the small town where he spent childhood summers. Despite his medical skills, his rude manner alienates locals as he battles hidden phobias and struggles with personal connections.
60   Metascore
2026 Comedy, Drama

The Closer

7 Seasons
Deputy Police Chief Brenda Leigh Johnson, formerly Atlanta police officer and CIA-trained interrogator, is given the opportunity to run her own division of elite officers of the Los Angeles Police Department. Her unusual procedure for obtaining confessions, blatant disregard for politics, and southern accent make her a marked woman. However, with all the bluster and bravado, she still maintains her title, The Closer.
68   Metascore
2005 Suspense, Drama

The Rookie

8 Seasons
Six months into his career as a cop, John Nolan will be put to the test as he looks to figure out what kind of cop he ultimately wants to be.
64   Metascore
2018 Action & Adventure, Suspense, Drama

Stranger Things

5 Seasons
When a young boy vanishes, a small town uncovers a mystery involving secret experiments, terrifying supernatural forces and one strange little girl.
74   Metascore
2016 Drama, Fantasy, Horror, Suspense, Science Fiction

11.22.63

1 Season
A teacher discovers a time portal that leads to October 21, 1960, and goes on a quest to try to prevent the assassination of John F. Kennedy, which is complicated by the presence of Lee Harvey Oswald and the fact that he's falling in love with the past itself.
69   Metascore
2016 Drama, Suspense, Science Fiction