Finally Caught Season 1 Episodes

Episode 1

Pentola-Clark

Shortly after a young nurse, Debra Clark, ends up beaten and shot to death in her apartment, her lover's wife reveals her knowledge about the affair, yet it takes nearly 40 years to match DNA evidence found at the crime scene to implicate the man man behind it all.

Episode 2

Gouldin

Sat, Jan 24, 202660 mins

The sporadic appearance of a dozen brutalized mannequins and six different incidents of murder and assault, terrorizes residents of Elkridge, a small town in Maryland. It is 13 years until a DNA match implicates a local suspect as the killer.

Episode 3

Talley

Sat, Jan 24, 202660 mins

In 1991, a 77 year-old woman, Louise Talley, is found raped and murdered in her vandalized Nicetown neighborhood home in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. A man, Anthony Wright, is convicted and put behind bars. 23 years later, DNA analysis emerges implicating the real killer and clearing Wright.

Episode 4

Hoffman/O'Brien

When a popular high school cheerleader is abducted and found stabbed to death in a water retention tank, it takes several years until the murderer makes the mistake of implicating himself as a new victim giving the authorities the evidence needed to pin him to the brutal killing.

Episode 5

Hlavka

Sat, Jan 24, 2026

A young woman, Anna Hlavka, is found sexually assaulted and strangled in her bedroom after she was last seen outside her apartment after work. Police canvass the neighborhood and interrogate multiple suspects, but the case goes cold when leads go nowhere. Finally, nearly 40 years post-murder, a DNA match is found and someone is implicated as the woman's murderer.

Episode 6

Beard

Sat, Jan 24, 2026

After a multi-millionaire, Steven Beard, is shot in his own mansion and eventually succumbs to his wounds, it takes countless years until a family friend admits to the murder, but in a shocking twist, implicates the true mastermind behind the deadly plan.

Episode 7

Anderson

Sat, Jan 24, 2026

When a recently married woman, Carmina Anderson, is found shot to death in a camper, her husband claims it was an accident and the case is closed. 21 years later a dedicated daughter, new shocking interviews and autopsy findings uncover the true killer behind the gruesome murder.

Episode 8

Flagg

When a man claims to have found his young wife brutally stabbed to death in their new home, the police are left with no leads. It will take 23 years of investigative work and new DNA evidence to uncover the killer is related to the purchase of their starter house.

Episode 9

Harris

Sat, Jan 24, 202660 mins

After a young woman's corpse, Tracey Harris, is found in a nearby river, the evidence points towards her abusive husband Carl Harris. 30 years passes before a mysterious woman, Dawn Beasley, surfaces explaining how the true killer behind the gruesome murder is actually her own husband Jeff Beasley.

Episode 10

Smith/Lavigne

Sat, Jan 24, 2026

When the bodies of two college sweethearts, Kimberly Lavine and Edward Smith, are found on the side of a Washington highway, it takes another gruesome murder, one lone fingerprint and four long years of investigating to uncover the murderer is someone already convicted of abduction and rape.

Episode 11

Sherry

Sat, Jan 24, 2026

When a prominent lawyer and his respected wife are found shot to death in their own home, investigators piece together an odd scam against closeted homosexuals run by a mafia ring allowing them to discover the reasons and culprits behind the murders.

Episode 12

Baker

When a woman is found brutally bludgeoned to death in her bed, her estranged husband is suspected. 23 years later when a similar murder reveals new DNA evidence that matches the original cold case, a man who lived a few blocks away is implicated.

Episode 13

Slover

Sat, Jan 24, 2026

After Karyn Slover, an aspiring model, body is found dismembered in a lake, it takes authorities over a year to find DNA evidence relating back to a pet owned by her abusive husbands parents, shifting the investigation far closer than anyone could have ever imagined.

Episode 14

Tomaselli

Tue, Apr 11, 2023

When two daughters call 911 after finding their father, Anthony Tomaselli, dead on his couch, it takes over three years and an awkward love-triangle between them to uncover what actually happened and lock up a killer that nearly got away with the "perfect crime".

Episode 15

Shelly

Sat, Aug 10, 2024

A woman is found shot on her bathroom floor. Her boyfriend claims it is a suicide and the autopsy results come back showing the wounds as self-inflicted. But inconsistencies, like the fact that the victim had just packed up her car to take her kids to Arkansas, keep one investigator returning to the case. A break finally comes more then 10 years later, contradicting the story of events and reveal deception, uncovering the truth behind who killed her and the motive for murder being closer than once expected.

Episode 16

Steller/King

Sat, Aug 10, 2024

A woman and her live-in nephew are found brutally murdered on the floor of their kitchen in the small town of Middletown, Conneticut. When an answering machine recording of the murder is found, it takes 3 year to implicate the killer and convict a double murder.

Episode 19

Rasmussen

When a divorced woman married to a verbally abusive husband is found murdered in her bed, all signs point to him until his alibi rules him out, forcing the investigators to hunt for two years until they stumble across the murderer with a shady past that's closer than expected to the victim.

Episode 23

Triano

When a prominent millionaire is killed by a bomb in his car it takes thirteen long years until investigators are able to uncover a trail of secret love affairs, insurance policies and financial receipts to lead them to the most unassuming killer.

Episode 25

Nickell/Snow

When ingested Excedrin pills are found to have lead to several mysterious deaths around the city, investigators uncover a dubious murder plot. Revolving around insurance policies and uncovering a shocking truth, the killer is finally caught years after.