Join or Sign In

Sign in to customize your TV listings

Continue with Facebook Continue with email

By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

This Is Us Was Almost a Bad Movie With No Point

With... octuplets?!

Lindsay MacDonald

This Is Us was officially the best show to hit network TV last fall, and it's kind of hard to imagine a variation of this story that we wouldn't like to watch. One little anecdote about the original script, on the other hand, has us thanking our lucky stars we got the Pearson family we know and love instead of the alternative.

According to an in-depth look at the show from The Hollywood Reporter, creator and showrunner Dan Fogelman originally pitched the idea as a film script. The film would have followed eight strangers, building to the final reveal that they were all actually grown-up octuplets. The Big Eight somehow just doesn't pack the same emotional punch as The Big Three, am I right?

Fogelman apparently felt the same way, saying that while he loved each of the characters he created, every time he'd sit down to write, he'd end up asking himself, "What's the f*cking point of this?"

Watch This Is Us' Aww-Inducing Love Letter to Fans

For a writer, that is hands down the worst question to come away with in the writing process.

After inking a deal with Twentieth Century Fox Television though, Fogelman finally realized that the script he couldn't quite figure out would become an entirely different animal if adapted for TV, which is where the magic really started to happen. A few of the octuplets obviously had to go, including a soon-to-be divorced sister and a hotshot movie-star brother, but the heart and soul of the story remained -- and so did that ever-important twist. With the knowledge that the story would be ongoing instead of a 90-minute standalone, the Pearson family in all their glorious dysfunction was born.

And the rest, as they say, is Emmy-worthy history.

This Is Us returns for Season 2 on Tuesday, Sept. 26 at 9/8c on NBC.

Sterling K. Brown, Chrissy Metz; This Is Us

Sterling K. Brown, Chrissy Metz; This Is Us

Ron Batzdorff/NBC