Connor Paolo and Christa B. Allen Connor Paolo and Christa B. Allen

When Revenge returns in April, pill-popping rich girl Charlotte (Christa B. Allen) and her boyfriend Declan (Connor Paolo) will be enrolled as seniors at Collins Prep.

The actors admit they had visions of wizardry when they got their first look at their costumes: navy blazers, sweater vests and ties. All that was missing were capes and magic wands. "We were shooting in El Segundo High School while school was in session and the kids were like, 'What is this? Harry Potter?' recalls Christa. "It really does look like we're enrolled at Hogwarts."

And just like those Potter flicks, Connor teases, "by the time you see us in the school halls, some bad stuff is happening between us. It's a rather dark, contentious environment." Where's Dumbledore when you need him?

Subscribe to TV Guide Magazine now!