In 1908, a farmhouse in Indiana burned to the ground. In the basement, a headless woman's body was found, along with the bodies of Belle Gunness' three children. A search of the farm turned up a grim harvest of 13 dismembered bodies, buried throughout the property--men Belle had lured to the farm through lonely hearts newspaper advertisements. The question became, who was the headless woman found in the basement? Was Belle killed by another killer, or had the Black Widow staged her own death, using another innocent victim as her own body?