Join or Sign In

Sign in to customize your TV listings

Continue with Facebook Continue with email

By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

The Commitments Reviews

This typically slick but largely enjoyable Alan Parker offering is the story of the rise and demise of a young Irish soul band. As with his earlier film, FAME, Parker has attempted to capture the infectious energy of popular music; and as with his previous feature, MISSISSIPPI BURNING, the director has taken on an alien culture (this time that of the working-class, primarily Catholic North Side of Dublin) and reduced its complexities to a glib, commercial formula. When Jimmy Rabbitte (Robert Arkins) is asked by two friends to manage a dreadful wedding band, he takes the opportunity to begin building something more ambitious: an authentic soul outfit to be called The Commitments. The newly formed band immerse themselves in the soul classics as they begin struggling their way through rehearsals. Their working-class philosophy is spelled out by Jimmy: "The Irish are the blacks of Europe; Dubliners are the blacks of Ireland; and the North Siders are the blacks of Dublin. So say it loud: I'm black and I'm proud." The Commitments' music improves with predictable, if enjoyable speed. As they begin to develop a following on the pub circuit, the usual tensions start to manifest themselves. For all its emphasis on working-class integrity, THE COMMITMENTS is really FAME wrapped in streetwise packaging. All the cliches of the star-is-born subgenre are here, from the neatness with which the band members fall into place to the amazing rapidity with which they develop a professional sound (not to mention the implausibility of a group achieving such success by playing straight cover versions of classic soul songs). The whole thing has the feel of an extended sitcom--not surprising given the fact that Dick Clement and Ian La Frenais, veteran English TV writers, helped Roddy Doyle adapt his original novel for the screen. THE SNAPPER, a superior film, is also based on a Doyle novel about the Rabbitte family.