Alexandra Breckenridge, American Horror Story Alexandra Breckenridge, American Horror Story

Glee bosses Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk are used to making audiences cheer, but Wednesday night they did their best to make them cringe with the premiere of FX's American Horror Story. We want to know what you thought of this show — and what you think of every new series this season.

Vote: Which fall premieres won you over? Which flopped?

Did American Horror Story give you the willies? Would you trust that crazy maid? Will Jessica Lange's good neighbor act keep you coming back? Vote now! And remember to encourage your friends and other fans to vote.

Check back to see what TVGuide.com users think of your favorite — and least favorite — new shows for fall and the final rankings for the debuts.

Fall TV: Get the lowdown on this season's must-see new shows

When can you vote next? Here's a handy calendar to help you keep track.