Sleepy Hollowproved it still knows how to shock us earlier this week when Abbie (Nicole Beharie) accidentally time-traveled to the 1700s. (Not exactly the best place to be a black woman wearing pants.)

On the set: Go behind the scenes of Sleepy Hollow

Luckily, Abbie went far back enough that Ichabod was still around. So in Monday's finale, Abbie does what any good Witness would do and tracks down her partner. Unfortunately, Ichabod (Tom Mison) is a little more than skeptical of Abbie's "fanciful tales." But wouldn't you be if a strange woman showed up and starting talking about a demon Horseman of Death?

See their full encounter in the exclusive sneak peek below.