Robin Wright and Ben Foster have decided to end their engagement for a second time, People reports.

The pair met on the set of the 2011 film Rampart, and hit it off right away. Foster proposed to Wright in January 2014, but they called off the wedding in November of that year. However, Wright and Foster reconciled only to quietly split again a few months ago.

This would have been the second marriage for Wright, who was with Sean Penn until 2009.