The former Bachelorette, 29, and Stagliano, 27, tied the knot in her home state of Georgia. The bride wore a strapless Disney Bridal wedding gown with a birdcage veil and cowboy boots.
The couple were set up by Stephen's twin brother, Michael Stagliano from Jillian Harris' The Bachelorette run, and Holly Durst from Matt Grant's season of The Bachelor. (Michael and Durst were engaged, but have since broken up).
Stephen, a high school teacher, proposed to Pappas in August 2010.
Pappas first appeared on Brad Womack's first season of The Bachelor, before she became The Bachelorette later that year. She got engaged to Jesse Csincsak in July 2008, but they broke up later that year.