Growing up in Darien, Conn., Grace was friends with Win a Date with Tad Hamilton! co-star Kate Bosworth and was looked after by Sevigny, who let him stay up late. "I had such a crush on her," he said. The two later starred in school productions of Annie Get Your Gun and The Wizard of Oz.
Photo Credits: Matt Dinerstein/SHOWTIME; Jeff Kravitz/Getty Images; Ben Leuner / AMC; Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images; Frederick M. Brown, Getty Images; Getty Images; Frederick M. Brown/Getty Images; Venturelli, WireImage; Ron Batzdorff/NBC; Paramount Network; Matt Dinerstein/Showtime