Michael Desmond/The CW
2 of 16
The CW series that was supposed to mark Sarah Michelle Gellar's big return to television post-Buffy was canceled after just one season, leaving viewers to wonder what exactly happened to recovering drug addict Bridget Kelly and her twin sister Siobhan Martin, whose identity Bridget assumes. The show's loyal fanbase has launched several online petitions to revive the show, in order to gain answers to questions — What really happened to Malcolm? Will Siobhan try to get revenge on Bridget? — that remain unanswered.