2 of 37
Ted, Marshall and Lily meet as college freshmen at Wesleyan University (the alma mater of co-creators Carter Bays and Craig Thomas). Since he's high from "eating a sandwich," Marshall thinks Ted is the dean at first and that the dean will be his roommate. He and Lily meet when she comes over seeking help for her stereo. Meanwhile, north of the border, Robin Sparkles transforms herself into grunge rocker Robin Daggers and debuts a new song, "P.S. I Love You," during a career-ending performance at the Grey Cup. Who was the tune about? Not Dave Coulier, but Paul Schaffer.