Your Dancing with the Stars All-Stars Dream Cast!

Sabrina Bryan

Bryan, who was paired with Mark Ballas, was the show's first and most memorable shocking elimination, exiting Season 5 in 7th place despite being the front-runner. Even with only six dances, she had the third-highest season score average of 27, behind only the finalists, who danced 15 routines.

"Sabrina should definitely be in the mix. That was just a fiasco that season! People took for granted she had the votes and stopped voting for her." — echodobes