ABC Archive/Getty Images
2 of 14
Monaco, who was paired with Alec Mazo, was the first Dancing champ, but after fans of runner-up John O'Hurley complained that he was robbed, the two faced off in a grudge match, which O'Hurley won.
"I just hope Kelly Monaco is one of [the All-Stars]. DWTS pretty well stabbed her in the back the first season." — Debsafan